In March 1913, the Saint Paul’s Baptist Church voted to call the Rev. Isaiah Hines as its third Pastor. Under his leadership, a second Sanctuary was constructed to accommodate over 200 worshippers. Rev. Isaiah Hines was known for his spirited preaching and led the church for 15 years. On the first Sunday of June, 1928, Rev. Hines resigned. During the interim following his resignation, the Deacon Board was responsible for maintaining the spiritual and business affairs of the Church.